What is "Mind?"

Search
Go

Discussion Topic

Return to Forum List
Post a Reply
Messages 3101 - 3120 of total 4563 in this topic << First  |  < Previous  |  Show All  |  Next >  |  Last >>
eeyonkee

Trad climber
Golden, CO
Jul 16, 2014 - 04:58pm PT
Great post, jgill, but if I may retort. How would you know the difference whether you consciously decided to do something or unconsciously decided to do something and then had an after-the-fact sense of agency about it? The first part of this should not be difficult at all. We call in "instinct" in animals. They just tend to exhibit this range of behavior under this range of circumstances. Let's assume we do the same thing but in a much more sophisticated way. We just do something based on our "state" and the current circumstances in our world. That is not free will. We immediately "make sense" of this action based on memories...(and stuff).

This is no parlor trick. Separating action from sentience is really huge. It is my most important original thought in this discussion.
PSP also PP

Trad climber
Berkeley
Jul 16, 2014 - 05:39pm PT
BB'er said "Then i found Jesus. Early in my walk with Him, this 40 yro anger rose. So i took it to Him and laid it at His feet"


This is basicly the same thing as letting go of the attachment to "I" just a different style.Christian style. You let go of your anger ,which is "I" am angry. Christian style or Zen style doesn't matter as long as you do it.
Tvash

climber
Seattle
Jul 16, 2014 - 05:42pm PT
If Mike believes every action is perfect, we don't agree.

As I've tried to foist upon thee before, when you have a thousand wavering value engines all screaming for attention in different keys, one's 'choice' of action can vary. creativity proves that our decision engine is
really
fkn
complicated.

Plus, if your perceptions are off kilter - garbage in, garbage out.

All I'm saying is that it doesn't seem possible for one's consciousness to call any shots at all, because those shots have already been called by the the very same stuff from which consciousness emerges.

I'm now going to choose to have dinner with a beautiful woman, then walk the sculpture park.

Best I can do in this life.


BLUEBLOCR

Social climber
joshua tree
Jul 16, 2014 - 06:37pm PT

you are claiming that you are conscious "in the moment" but essentially unaware that you were later because you can't remember.

How about think back to "your" first awareness of being conscious at age 2/3. Where was your conscious before that? i don't think you/i can remember because our infant brains memory had not developed enough yet. Put together the fact that we just don't remember everything we put our eyes on and make the focal point in our conscious. Lets jump forward to when you were 7/8. You know you were conscious, but you can't remember hardly anything you were conscious of on any given day. i also think there are multiple layers of consciousness, and maybe your only thinking of one? Basically being aware enough to feel the poke of a stick? Open eyed awareness. i'm sitting here focused on the screen punching keys, conscious of each letter. Meanwhile, i hear the radio talk'in, the water cooler running, the dog lick'in my foot, it's hot,and so on. While my brain narrowly focuses no how to spell this word. My "full-time running,wide open awareness conscious" is keeping tabs of everything in my environment i'm not narrowly focused on. "keeping tabs" through my other senses. If i get cold, my narrowness will be interrupted and i'll turn off the cooler. Who tells you to pull the blanket back up when cold while your asleep? Your brain is prompted by a level of your conscious. Being cold is relative to what you consciously agree as warm.

Again, who really knows? i have ideas, i'm just trying to figure out words.
i'm dig'in Damasio's theory's,jus not some of his terminology.
Go check it out!



jgill

Boulder climber
Colorado
Jul 16, 2014 - 07:10pm PT
We just do something based on our "state" and the current circumstances in our world. That is not free will. We immediately "make sense" of this action based on memories...(and stuff) (eey)

Rather than try to refute this I will offer an example that may reinforce your assertion: Have you ever had the experience of an unexpected sudden loud noise or explosion while you were sleeping, perhaps dreaming, and awakening immediately but having the eerie experience of having had a dream that seems to have been lengthy and that led up to and incorporated the loud noise into its storyline? How could this possibly be? It seems to defy logic and suggest even a bit of time-travel into the past, but that, I'm sure, is an illusion.

Your post probably refers, as well, to the moments of reflection and decision-making prior to "doing something" doesn't it?

All I'm saying is that it doesn't seem possible for one's consciousness to call any shots at all, because those shots have already been called by the very same stuff from which consciousness emerges (Tvash)

Suppose that "stuff" sends up the signal for the "I" in one's consciousness to make a decision and enjoy the sensation of free will?

MH2

climber
Jul 16, 2014 - 07:14pm PT
I also have wondered if my brain has plotted dreams out in advance. It certainly feels that way sometimes. Or maybe it works backwards from some point? Or perhaps there are several parallel lines of dream?
MH2

climber
Jul 16, 2014 - 07:16pm PT
I have memories that I think were formed quite early, but have only a vague notion of when they date from.

I think it is reasonable to guess that babies have a level of consciousness. We can only guess at what another person is thinking and feeling from what they do. Baby's brains are probably busy absorbing the world around and learning to organize movement and don't have much motivation to impress an audience with their erudition, but they squeal and squall for food, attention, and clean-me-up. And they babble beautiful somethings.


Here are a couple examples of what might be objective evidence of consciousness, if you are not too finicky about the definition.


Face recognition








Will, want, need, strive, or crave


jgill

Boulder climber
Colorado
Jul 16, 2014 - 07:28pm PT
Here are a couple of examples that might fit with eeyonkee's theses:

When I was about ten and living in a suburb outside Houston some friends and I had played baseball and were walking home. I started to show off by spinning a bat in the air and catching it by the handle. Then I missed and it struck me in the head, knocking me down. I didn't loose consciousness, but I had the strangest experience when the bat struck: I saw a deep blue field like the sky with a number of perfect, five pointed solid white stars - just like you might see in a comic book.

More recent, a few years ago I had been sitting for a long time, then got up a little too fast, almost blacking out. But another instant visual appeared: a plane filled with small flashing squares of various colors, exactly like interference patterns on a digital TV. The Matrix, maybe?


;>)
MikeL

Trad climber
SANTA CLARA, CA
Jul 16, 2014 - 10:51pm PT
Ed: . . . the only way you are "conscious" is through a third person consensus that you are.

What? The sentence is illogical and nonsensical. How could one's own consciousness come through another? The very essence of consciousness is subjectivity. Explain yourself, please.

Tvash: If Mike believes every action is perfect, we don't agree.

Actions are a subset of the totality. There is an acorn, and it is perfect. It gets watered, bathed in soils and moisture, and it grows into an oak tree. Every part and phase is perfect, and every so-called action is too. Without any "action," nothing changes--but everything changes. So actions are just transitions in states of being. Look at the acorn and the oak tree and all of the circumstances and causes that they are a part and parcel of. To call one thing a cause and another thing an effect is heavy-handed bracketing--no different than looking at a painting and seeing the left-hand corner as an effect of the right hand corner. Everything is dynamic, and yet everything is one. You could say that everything is movement, but nothing is going anywhere. Everything is right here right now in your consciousness. It's sort of like a movie: there seems to be all of that action and movement and effect, but looking closely one can see that it's all just what occurs on a screen.

(Why am I still awake tonight? I'm so tired of unpacking boxes upon boxes of household goods. One glass of wine, and I'm out for the count.)
eeyonkee

Trad climber
Golden, CO
Jul 17, 2014 - 04:28am PT
Thanks for your support, jgill:)

And, HFCS, now that I reflect back on 2006, I realize I was just a darn, fool kid back then.
Tvash

climber
Seattle
Jul 17, 2014 - 05:08am PT
"Suppose that "stuff" sends up the signal for the "I" in one's consciousness to make a decision and enjoy the sensation of free will? "

There's no 'other' place to 'send' such a signal. If consciousness IS a person experiencing those signals, then the deed is already done. That is to say, the decision has already been made, and one experiences the final result of that decision (slightly) after the fact.

Ie, the last thing the avalanche does is wipe out your cabin at its base.

Randisi

Social climber
Dalian, Liaoning
Jul 17, 2014 - 05:09am PT
What? The sentence is illogical and nonsensical. How could one's own consciousness come through another? The very essence of consciousness is subjectivity. Explain yourself, please.

Not all philosophies consider subjectivity to be some kind of hermetically sealed box that you can't get out of.

Some philosophies even claim that it is the other that incites consciousness, or that consciousness is first and foremost intersubjectivity.

But I have little desire to explain these ideas here.
eeyonkee

Trad climber
Golden, CO
Jul 17, 2014 - 05:15am PT
Totally on board with you, Tvash.
go-B

climber
Cling to what is good!
Jul 17, 2014 - 06:16am PT

Credit: go-B

John 20:30 And truly Jesus did many other signs in the presence of His disciples, which are not written in this book; 31 but these are written that you may believe that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God, and that believing you may have life in His name.

...I love John, Jesus truly is the only brighter side of life!
MH2

climber
Jul 17, 2014 - 06:25am PT
Not all philosophies consider subjectivity to be some kind of hermetically sealed box that you can't get out of. (Randisi)


Thanks for that. Tatiana and Krista Hogan appear to leak into one another. Probably no one knows exactly how someone else is feeling, but most people have a degree of empathy. Actors talk about being in character for a role, and trying to think and feel like the character in order to behave like the character.
Randisi

Social climber
Dalian, Liaoning
Jul 17, 2014 - 06:34am PT
For example, here's a random sentence I just this minute translated:

The entire world becomes subject at the same time as it integrates the objects.

--Michel Serres
MH2

climber
Jul 17, 2014 - 06:50am PT
Come to think of it, after a brief look at Michel Serres, a tranlsator would be especially attuned to what we call subjectivity. Trying to translate evocative prose from one language to another would require a sense of what the author is trying to say, not just what they did say, it seems. Words are so context-sensitive. Machine language translation is difficult to implement because of how much of culture one needs to know and understand.
another nickname

Social climber
Yazoo Ms
Jul 17, 2014 - 06:58am PT
I barely know Kant and almost certainly misunderstand him, but I thought he figured most of "reality" was in some realm apart from time & space (noumenal) & notions of "mind" would therefore be exclusively "phenomenal" & somewhat of an illusion.

I don't suppose it truly matters, but they say physics is coming round to the idea that time and space don't exist -- at least at certain scales & energy levels.
Randisi

Social climber
Dalian, Liaoning
Jul 17, 2014 - 07:07am PT
I barely know Kant and almost certainly misunderstand him, but I thought he figured most of "reality" was in some realm apart from time & space (noumenal) & notions of "mind" would therefore be exclusively "phenomenal" & somewhat of an illusion.

Philosophy too has made progress since that time.
MikeL

Trad climber
SANTA CLARA, CA
Jul 17, 2014 - 07:43am PT
Randisi: Not all philosophies consider subjectivity to be some kind of hermetically sealed box that you can't get out of.

Get out of your consciousness, and tell us what that's like. I think you'll find yourself in a place that Largo has been attempting to point to.

There is no philosophy needed to experience consciousness. The compulsion to explain consciousness, when it's right in front of you, is sort of like explaining the taste of sugar or explaining the experience of climbing. What's the purpose or the use? The only point is to simply experience another experience. It's all experience.

You like philosophies, don't you, my friend? I think you're getting yourself all balled-up in thoughts and concepts, which is surely itself an experience, but it tends to fall into a weird regress, like Alice in Wonderland. Philosophies are rabbit-holes, but people like them because they think they can pin something down with them. Nothing can be pinned down.

MH2: Trying to translate evocative prose from one language to another would require a sense of what the author is trying to say, not just what they did say, it seems. Words are so context-sensitive.

Look up "literary theory." This field of study has exploded and fragmented over the past 50 years, and it's very difficult to keep track of what folks are saying. One thing is for sure, though: any text (to include this one) is highly problematical, even to an author who writes it. See Derrida's works.

Once you see that language presents aconstant movement of differences--of words referring to other words definitionally and in opposition to one another--you will see that there can be no stable restingpoint. This means you can no longer appeal to reality as a refuge independent oflanguage. Everything in reality is unstable and ambiguous, both of which are inherent in language.
Messages 3101 - 3120 of total 4563 in this topic << First  |  < Previous  |  Show All  |  Next >  |  Last >>
Return to Forum List
Post a Reply
 
Our Guidebooks
Check 'em out!
SuperTopo Guidebooks


Try a free sample topo!

 
SuperTopo on the Web

Review Categories
Recent Route Beta
Recent Gear Reviews